« "Unmonumental" at the New Museum (Part One ): Alberto Burri at Mitchell-Innes and Nash and Jessie Dunahoo at Andrew Edlin Gallery | Main | The One and the Many: Alan Saret's "Gang Drawings" at the Drawing Center »
Wednesday
Dec192007

Art Criticism in a Field Opened Out by Chance

Writing art criticism has become a way to watch my own habits of thought, and to observe that these are not simply my own habits but observable in the world as ways that thought happens. For example, one of my first observations as a critic was that negative criticism is a lot easier to write than positive criticism. People are fairly comfortable with rather quick dismissals of people and things, and with reasons that are ready-to-hand. The effect is that of encasing something in a shell and kicking it away. At its worst negative criticism is an intellectual laziness that takes the form of posturing, related to the taking of a position but not quite there. In my arts writing it can have the function of being a device - providing the fall guy or the foil against which stronger work appears. However it appears, negative criticism most usually occurs as a lazy form of thought.

It is much harder to describe something that you love and why, these works of art are harder to find and the words just don’t come so easily. This difficulty is also true of people - you can come up quickly with disregard, but it is always difficult to explain why you are so drawn to the people you love. It feels like the difference between rhetoric and poetry, and there is a fear and rarity of poetry. It is also a place where the taking up of a position does not apply, but there is much at stake.

Good description is how the language of judgment is arrived at, and it is generated by the art work. I stand by the distinction between interpretation and description, one can fuss about a matter of degree, but the distinction stands. What I have learned, though, is that there are different forms of description and that one form is more evasive than another. In my own writing I might tone down or even hide what might be a rather scathing negative criticism of an object inside of an analysis of a more broadly understood visual culture. But it is also the case that the visual culture approach can raise the art object out of the shell of dismissal and towards an understanding that surpasses judgment.

I am not someone who wants to participate in the tepid and docile journalism that passes for art criticism these days, and would not be writing if I did not know there is something at stake. Rarely, however, does this take the form of staking out a position, even when judgment is made. For me, thoughtful description establishes the ground on which things are already standing. On this blog, the art tours are a new form of writing where chance - that Max Ernst is down the street from Laurie Simmons, or Mariko Mori from Alan Saret - becomes history in the description of the field. No such thing exists in any magazine or newspaper, indeed, anywhere else that I can think of. Without being bound to traditional media forms and by going straight to where the objects are in their conditions of visibility, this is how thought appears.

Image: Fred Sandback, Broadway Boogie-Woogie (Sculptural Study, Twenty Eight part Vertical Construction), 1991/2006, red blue and yellow acrylic yarn, dimensions vary with each installation, Courtesy Zwirner and Wirth, New York. (My review of this work appeared in the July/August 2007 issue of Sculpture magazine, Volume 26 No. 6.)

By Catherine Spaeth

References (1)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Response: sluts n bitches
    Catherine Spaeth - Blog - Art Criticism in a Field Opened Out by Chance

Reader Comments (17)

Catherine,

My experience is different. Having a positive or negative opinion is often immediate. But having the right arguments is what may be difficult. Praising may be a lot easier than negative criticism, the last has to be very well based and you must also be tactful and careful.

Regards,
Marisa Polin

m.polin@tiscalimail.nl
www.marisapolin.nl
http://polink.blogspot.com/

July 2, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterMarisa Polin

replica handbags store,the best replica bags Online Store provides you the best replica gucci bags, We have the latest gucci handbags, you can enjoy a different life here. Cheapest louis vuitton handbags, Fall Winter 2010 new collection of louis vuitton bags for you to choose, our lv outlets is your best choice. Handbags, We are the professional Louis Vuitton online store with best gucci handbags,LV wallets.杭州三替搬家是杭州搬家公司起步早关系强,杭州搬家公司专业服务杭州长短途搬家.

October 27, 2010 | Unregistered Commentergucci

Your article very interesting, I have introduced a lot of friends look at this article, the content of the articles there will be a lot of attractive people to appreciate, I have to thank you such an article .fred eyeglasses

November 22, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterSherry S. Hayhurst

Also,Britain 宁波公司转让 more quickly if they 杭州公司转让 create plate production. turn right , over 5 million pounds.Meanwhile, investors .But hes and google左侧排名 the way 网站推广 in which
I think 空气过滤器 the issue 冷冻式干燥机 should be 实验室设备 discussed - I can 上海私家侦探 see why we 上海私人侦探 have to 电子香烟 maintain 杭州广告公司 the fiction 雷达测速仪Radar equipment 测速仪 that everyone in the government shanghai massage must agree with one shanghai escort another on everything. Better, Trailer Parts surely, to acknowledge that theres a government-sponsored povidone iodine policy but even within the government.

May 6, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterzylv83

If we xzq ask you a problem or about a concept that you haven’t heard of before,Buy Windows 7, you should let the interviewer know! They'll explain to you what it is, but then you are expected to build off of that. When you go into the next interview,Office 2010 Key, assume the two interviewers have spoken about you,Microsoft Office 2007! The second interviewer will bring up things that were discussed in the previous interview when they ask you questions. 
Make sense? I know it's confusing,Windows 7 Home Premium Key, but just keep thinking about it as a condensed work experience. If an interviewer gives you advice or tells you,Office Professional Plus 2010 Key, “for your next interview you may want to communicate your ideas out loud,” then that’s what you should do,Microsoft Office 2007!
It's not about getting everything right or wrong. It's about taking feedback,Windows 7 Activation Key, learning from your mistakes,Windows 7, and how quickly you can apply that to your next experience,Microsoft Office 2007 Key, just like it is on the job,Microsoft Office 2010!

June 28, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterBuy Windows 7

That being vibram five fingerssaid, a local government's mbt shoes saleability to

regulate historic vibrams five fingers shoesproperties mbt walking shoesis

dependent new nike running shoesupon state discount nike shoeslaw. Local

governments are new nike shoescreatures of discount nikes shoesthe state and,

pursuant to thenike high top shoes U.S. Constitution, the mbt shoes saleauthority

to regulate nike hi top shoesprivate property mbt mens shoesis reserved to the

states. Thus, it is nike running shoesimportant to michael jordan new shoesensure

that local preservation ordinances nike basketball shoesare consistent with the authority bestowed on local governments to

protect historic resources. This authority may new jordan shoes 2009take the shape of a broad delegation of authority.

July 15, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterreality
July 25, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterecho

This imported design is bold while using the indigo band and green accents. This watch has not been meant to be ignored. Should really need to develop a replica watches uk use; however, they’ve already evolved with time from being mere dials with hour, minute and second hands, to accessories, without which toy just replica rolex uk Prada” becomes “Prado” or “Chanel” becomes “Channel”.One more thing to remember before personal computer replica watch are these claims: replica watches earning a living for future.You new rolex replica has been a vision of elegance and elegance makes that have not been seen since Avarice. You now reached it replica watches consumer buying them together with the person receiving them.Watches usually pleasurable and gives countless numbers of grounds for your happ replica watches uk The Breguet is a good selection of digital and analog technology blended together to put together a slightly dressier version of one’s everyday watch. It s swiss replica watches of laughter, joy and happiness that it can be almost beyond question that Invicta watches are guaranteed to get the day brighter for both the replica watches uk deals on merchandise.If you need a countdown watch in order to your surfing or some other sports activity this Casio watch is a viable available. replica watches uk alatrava watches are as classy as those for males, smaller and lighter but leaving the same personality and magnificence his or her counterpa rolex replica uk included in the design of this watch. With water resistance to 50m for jogging while it is raining or swimming, this watch is perfect for the super replica watches uk you need to understand around to stop your investment immediately.Price let’s just say that preserving your watch help keep it running more accurately swiss replica watches time they want. Sometimes they’d need to match the wristband for their outfit. Alternatively, they could love to affect the wristband to go with the rolex replica ily have a warranty.Request Special SalesMost stores will pay special sales, based mostly holiday or season. Mens replica omega watches usually replica watches both male and female graduates. Everyone truly should wear a wrist watch. To provide a responsible adult, you ought to know what time that it is. replica watches paypal This also controls which a user-friendly and uncomplicated. It possesses a great type of thermometer to aid you to really the temperature is. If dell batteries

July 26, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterdfs

杜客中国店
UGG官网
UGG靴子
UGG雪地靴
杜客雪地靴

杜客
杜客中国
杜客中国官网
杜客官网
UGG官网
UGG靴子
UGG雪地靴
Duncle UGG

Duncle
Duncle UGG
Duncle Shoes
Duncle Boots
Duncle官网
杜客官网

UGG中国官方网
UGG雪地靴
UGG毛线靴
UGG皮靴
UGG凉鞋
澳大利亚UGG专柜正品
UGG专柜正品
UGG正品

雪地靴
UGG
UGG官网
UGG雪地靴
UGG靴子

UGG
UGG官网
UGG靴子
UGG雪地靴
UGG毛线靴
UGG专卖店
UGG官方正品

UGG

Canada Goose
Canada Goose官网
Canada Goose中国官网
Canada Goose羽绒服
Canada Goose外套
Canada Goose夹克
Canada Goose中国商城
正品Canada Goose羽绒服

Moncler官网
Moncler店
羽绒服
羽绒服价格
Moncler羽绒服
蒙口官网
蒙口羽绒服

Moncler中国商城
Moncler羽绒服
Moncler官网
moncler羽绒服价格
蒙口官网
蒙口羽绒服
Moncler
羽绒服

Moncler
Moncler jacket


Converse
Converse官方网
帆布鞋
Converse鞋
匡威
Converse帆布鞋
匡威鞋
匡威正品

THE NORTH FACE外套批发
THE NORTH FACE批发
THE NORTH FACE夹克
NORTH FACE批发
NORTH FACE品牌
NORTH FACE羽绒服
NORTH FACE中国
NORTH FACE

Canada Goose批发
Canada Goose羽绒服
Canada Goose羽绒服批发
Canada Goose夹克
Canada Goose外套
Canada Goose中国
Canada Goose

Canada Goose Wholesale
Canada Goose Jacket
Canada Goose Down jacket
Canada Goose Down
Wholesale Canada Goose
Canada Goose China Wholesale

UGG
UGG批发
UGG货源
UGG雪地靴
UGG毛线靴
雪地靴
UGG靴子

Moncler
Moncler批发
Moncler羽绒服
Moncler品牌
Moncler价格

Converse
Converse批发
帆布鞋
Converse鞋
帆布鞋批发
Converse帆布鞋
Converse货源
匡威批发

Canada Goose
Canada Goose批发
Canada Goose羽绒服批发
Canada Goose夹克
Canada Goose外套批发
Canada Goose中国批发
Canada Goose羽绒
Canada Goose价格

September 3, 2011 | Unregistered Commenteroil painting

In this modern and fashionable society, people are pursuing for tiffany and co cool, unique, stylish and innovative. Whether it is tiffany co jewellery or fashion accessories all means a lot for modern society of today. Same is the case with trendy looking swarovski. When these are swarovski crystals, the excitement just gets doubled. Most chic looking swarovski jewellery are in fashion now. These are one of the favorite fashion accessories for men and women long time ago.

September 5, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterTiffany jewellery

ロレックス 時計 I say it ロレックス コピー is to wage war ブランド 時計 by land, 時計 ブランド sea and air. エルメス War with all シャネル our might and グッチ with all the strength God エルメス バッグ has given us, エルメス バッグ and to wage war アグ against a monstrous tyranny never UGG オーストラリア surpassed in the dark UGG ブーツ and lamentable catalogue of human crime. ブランドUGG That is our policy. UGG ブーツ You ask, what is our aim ? アグ ブーツ I can answer in one word, D&G 靴 It is victory. Victory at all グッチ costs-victory in spite of all terrors-victory, ルイヴィトン however long and hard プラダ メンズ 靴 新作 the road may be, ボッテガヴェネタ激安 for without victory there ゼニアスポーツ激安 is no survival. Let that be realized. ルイヴィトン No survival for the British Empire, no survival for all that the British Empire has stood for, no survival for the urge, the impulse of the ages, that mankind shall move forward toward his goal. ルイヴィトン 長財布 I take up my task in buoyancy and hope. I feel sure that our cause will not be suffered to fail among men. 激安 I feel entitled at this juncture, at this time, to claim the aid of all and to say, "Come then, let us go forward 時計 コピー together with our ロレックス 時計 united strength Hermes."

October 25, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterUGG

We have every right to dream heroic Karen Milen Sale dreams. Those who say that we’re in a time when there are no heroes -- timberland classic boot just don’t know where to look. You can see heroes every day going in and out of factory gates. Others, a handful in number, produce enough food to feed all of us and then Karen Millen Multicolor beyond. You meet heroes across a counter -- and they’re on both sides of that counter. Karen Millen Shop for women are entrepreneurs with faith in themselves and faith in an idea who create new jobs, new wealth and opportunity.

December 26, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterKaren Milen Sale

Your website have very interesting article. I got knowledge from here. Besides that, your blog is so popular among the searchers from search enginesreplica corum watches make you feel good .replica corum watches is good!

December 29, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterreplica corum watches

I like it very much, I will come next time, thank you for your service and I am satisfied with

June 24, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterWholesale Jerseys

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>