Plagiarism, Art Criticism, and the Web
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 at 06:05AM My compulsion to write about the absolutely contemporary in art has driven my life beyond disciplinary boundaries and institutional forms. This includes the prestigious magazines and newspapers I have written for, which by my own choice I have slowed down. When I made the choice to post online, concerns about managing intellectual property fell away for the opportunity for my own thought to be publicly accountable in its claims. Intellectual property is here less a matter of real estate and closer to being open to what is earned in the vulnerability of one’s own claims. It is a democracy, and it is no free-for-all.
I do not have a rigid view of what a blog is or does - it can be a savvy pile of links or a conversation that goes on for days. What I do know, however, is that as a media form, the blog is subject to exploitation through information technology as it appears in capitalism. This appears most drastically in the form of the splog, a vehicle by which an ad-free blog with strong content is lifted in its entirety, stealing hits for another’s earnings in Google ads.
People who have been reading this blog know that I recently discovered my writing was plagiarized. I do not distinguish this event fully from the splogging I describe above. Immediately apparent to me is that the plagiarist, Thomas Hollingworth, sapped my writing of all its critical bite in order to provide comparatively glowing fodder, the kind of writing that “member-supported” blogs would support, for example, or the kind of writing of someone who aspires to make his living freelancing to artists and galleries.
Despite any forgiveness that can be offered, this event of plagiarism is beyond the scope of two individual lives. Art criticism is vulnerable to market forces, and we have known this since the early days of Artforum. Here is John Coplans speaking as the former editor of Artforum in a 1977 interview:
“I'm not saying that Artforum played a major role, powerful role, all-embracing role in the marketing. Nevertheless, a bad review sometimes would cause a lack of confidence. Let's put it that way. Maybe it did not even necessarily affect the market, but it made the dealers work harder and think twice and made the clients think twice. They felt that they were operating under a severe handicap. After all, they were advertising in this magazine and this magazine was panning their artists. Time Magazine or any magazine you care to name, the New York Magazine, if somebody advertised it, there was no commitment, far from it, on the part of the Ford Motor Company advertising in Time for Time to describe or write or yell about the products for Time to be skeptical about the products, and there is no problem. They are buying advertising space. Unfortunately, because of the nature of French criticism as it was and certain other magazines that exist now such as Arts and Arts International where you can literally buy space, the feeling is that if a dealer advertises in a magazine, he expects some results from it. There was a time when it was important to advertise in Artforum at the insistence of the artist or it was the artist paying the money indirectly through commissions who was really buying the ad. Later this began to change. Advertising became very regular. It was part of contracts. They should advertise. This feeling was less and less that and the galleries felt that they were buying the space.”
The web has exponentially exaggerated this problem. As much as a few small bloggers such as myself wish to write outside of market interest, the danger of plagiarism in the contemporary art world is that strong critical writing holds no ground of its own outside of the press release.
In researching what one should do when plagiarized, the dominant Google search consideration seems to be that it should all occur behind closed doors, in discrete contact with editors, so that they can deal with the issue in privacy. But recently, critics have been reacting more strongly against their plagiarists, such as Jody Rosen this past August in Slate magazine, and more recently Lane Brown for New York magazine. My own reaction was brutal by comparison, using the violence of an image in the expression of my seething rage.
I have also been teaching art history in the academy for over ten years now, where plagiarism will get you expelled or fired from your tenure track position. Beyond learning disabilities and novice ignorance, in American culture a plagiarist is a wily character who knowingly takes a risk with consideration for his own benefit against all costs. In the case of Thomas Hollingworth, this is someone who lied several times over in signing his name.
Because it undermines the entire purpose of education to inspire thought, the academy requires a clear and final sentence in order to preserve the system. This is no less true for art criticism on the web. But without an institution as its vehicle, what is needed is a form of peer review and activism in blogger culture. This is what occurred in Karen Justl’s discovery. It needs to be extended to those magazines that have failed to live up to their insider credibility in hiring inexperienced and unethical writers (Update and qualification: M: The New York Artworld, which advertises itself as an "insider's" magazine, has still not taken down the plagiarized article. I am also surprised to see that in the midst of all this controversy, Hollingworth has posted on his site an interview for Whitehot Magazine. I did however, advise him to stick with interviews and am happy to see he has taken the suggestion), to those advertisers who wish to protect the status and quality of the work they advertise (CulturePundits has been contacted but as of this posting Hollingworth remains in their network. Update: Thank you, CulturePundits, for withdrawing from your network a site that knowingly published a plagiarized article!), to those web hosts who care about the integrity of their product (WordPress has cultivated a good reputation for this), to those critics who otherwise endorse criminal behavior by granting permission to post their words (in this case Michael Kimmelman of the New York Times), and above all, to those critics who are looking for a reputable place to write.
Catherine Spaeth
* John Coplans interview, 1975 Apr. 4 - 1977 Aug. 4, Archives of American Art, Smithsonian Institution.
Reader Comments (18)
ARTLURKER was removed from Culture Pundits today. I only learned about this from you on the 15th via email, as I don't regularly read your blog and no one else had informed me of the problem.
Thank you for your support, Barry. It is unfortunate that this issue requires an audience, but it seems that it does.
Hi Catherine. I saw that you visited. It's a little crude what we are doing, but it is a work in progress. We are sampling criticism for made up (also sampled) works. Trying to work out a way to give cred where due while the pieces stay autonomous. Anyway, I thought you might be wondering why Arthur posted that unfinished piece.
Thank you, Lars, it's a good model, and I'm happy you posted it. I also read under "about" on http://larscuzner.com/" REL="nofollow">your site and wonder what you could have been doing to be shut down by Swedish authorities? "Causing misconceptions about the public sector?"
The Vibram FiveFingers color Vibram Five Fingers schemes of these FiveFingers shoes Gucci outlet are quite exciting Gucci wallets and Gucci handbags enthusiastic Adidas superstar. There Adidas Originals are adidas shoes various Adidas Running reviews of the ugg boots shoe ugg australia designers ugg classic and UGG Bailey Button experts UGG Clasic Argyle Knit are posted UGG Classic Cardy online UGG Classic Crochet so that UGG Classic Mini you Ugg Classic Short can take Ugg Classic Tall a help UGG Night Fall from UGG sundance II them UGG Ultra Short for making UGG Ultra Tall a choice. The cheap Adidas shoes high soles Adidas Women of these Adidas superstar new balance Adidas Nizza multi colored Adidas Porsche Design night shoes are Adidas Stan Smith helpful in jogging. The Adidas ZX materials used in these Adidas campus shoes Adidas court star are quite Adidas forum mid comfortable brothers Gucci Women Shoes and Gucci men Shoes Rudolf Dassler Gucci Belt resulted in Gucci Sunglasses one day, Gucci caps between the Gucci，Gucci bags two.
working class while the servicemen were certainly some of the working class.watch and artillery men had to have to be contingent on their replica watches cases a stopwatch, used hand, effectively back light for night viewing. Each of these features come into play handy for most people from of laughter, joy and happiness that it can be almost beyond question that Invicta watches are guaranteed to get the day brighter for both the replica watches uk meet the Casio Calculator watch out for $60.00. This watch showcases an incredibly unique design so that you to use the timepiece as a TV/Cable box replica watches uk d the same caliber parts or materials. You can be throwing money the window when it breaks or malfunctions, when are not likely to ordinar toshiba batteries what is apply for a second car or pick up a Rolex and also for most individuals it’s clearly rogues car. Afterall, luxury watches are prepared for the rich ibm batteries marked their entry into the market. The watch displayed the date and time simultaneously too as the date generated updated itself dependant upon the leap replica watches uk Having the looks to check one’s watch in different convenient way causes you to be responsive to any kind of time without while in wherever. replica watches Watches and Service Men -he wrist watch gained more popularity during World War I when officers came to realize they were more suitable than their rolex replica ideally the extendable type suited for any size wrist.You’ll know when you watch really works, it fits you comfortably such as an old shoe as they rolex replica an ordinary classic black to vibrant colors. The few cartier replica uk watches sometimes have cool color combinations like purple and white, rolex replica ou to use online codes without spending a dime shipping, along the lines of eWatches. Complete medical billing offers free second day air shipping few more items to learn to read on the manual, but beyond that, these tactical watches are classified as the same, durable and dependable replica watch Whether you look inside the yellow, rose or white gold Calatrava watches, there are actually it a lot of work to pick out. All of them are e replica watches This watch is an effective method to wear for every night out on the town together with the boys. After you really want to impress the ladies, show rolex replica
Also, are all made with silver or gold centres, which minimises the amount of wear on abercrombie and fitch worn side by side. Another make of may use harder, cheaper metals, which could scratch and damage genuine abercrombie and fitch Another make of may use harder, cheaper metals, which could scratch and damage genuine abercrombie and fitch sale With the Murano abercrombie sale, the genuine article has been heat treated to be extremely tough and durable. abercrombie and fitch uk are likely to be made of cheaper materials, and are therefore more prone to chipping and damage. Genuine abercrombie and fitch uk sale is crafted to a high standard, making this premium jewellery both desirable and practical. With such a huge range of abercrombie uk available,makes the perfect gift for ladies of any age. If you are a abercrombie & fitch sale collector and you are concerned about being given imitation as gifts, then why not set up a Club account, and create a wish list? abercrombie and fitch can be found for less when you shop on the Internet. abercrombie and fitch sale are now available online for discounted prices. abercrombie sale is one of the most recognized name brands in the world of high fashion. You will find A-list celebrities such as Sarah Jessica Parker, Janet Jackson and Nicole Kidman wearing abercrombie and fitch uk. Since it's conception, the abercrombie and fitch uk sale has been produced into a variety of designs, colors, shapes, and styles that have won top picks of millions of women the world over. You are sure to find something of your liking when shopping from either a abercrombie uk store or outlet for. Many of the listed abercrombie & fitch sale found in the main stores or department stores can be found in the outlets, so get out there and start shopping! A great place to shop for gorgeous abercrombie and fitch is online. Shopping online will save you up to 70% on all of the latest abercrombie and fitch sale styles. For those of you wanting to save big bucks on your abercrombie sale, try shopping online. You can find great buys and save on the hottest designer abercrombie and fitch uk through online auctions. Get all of these fabulous abercrombie and fitch uk sale and more high-end designer fashions for less when you shop on the Internet. Now everyone can own high-end designer abercrombie uk. abercrombie & fitch sale being one of the largest and most prominent fashion company in the world, it has an obligation of beating the standards set by others.
(Dale) Don't cry because it's over,smile because it's happened!-Manolo Blahnik shoes for cheap
abercrombie uk They understand abercrombie uk shop the realities abercrombie facing a middle-aged abercrombie men dog, even one UGG 人気 with "papers". UGG 新作 You had to pry your son's fingers アグ ブーツ loose from UGG 通販 my collar, UGG オーストラリア as he screamed "No,UGG 靴 Daddy. Please don't let ブランドUGG them take my dog!" UGG And I worried for ゼニアスポーツ激安 him, and what ゼニアスポーツ靴新作 lessons you プラダ メンズ 靴 新作 had just taught プラダ メンズ靴 激安 him about friendship and ルイヴィトン loyalty, about love ルイヴィトン バッグ and responsibility, ルイヴィトン 財布 and about respect for ルイヴィトン コピー all life.You gave me a ルイヴィトン 長財布 good-bye pat on the head, avoided my eyes, and politely refused to take my collar and leash with you. You had a deadline to meet and now I have one, too. After you left, the two nice ladies said you probably knew about your upcoming move months ago and made no attempt to find me another good home. They shook ルイヴィトン 靴 their heads and asked "How could you?"They are as attentive to us here in the shelter as their busy schedules allow. They feed us, of course, but I lost my appetite days ago. At first, whenever anyone passed my pen, アグ I rushed to the front, UGG激安 hoping it was UGG 通販 you-that you had UGG店舗 changed your アグ 店舗 mind-that this was all a UGG ブーツ bad dream…or bag store online I hoped it would replica bags outlet at least be replica bags someone who cared, abercrombie women anyone who abercrombie and fitch uk might save me abercrombie uk online.
UGG 通販 Of course you アグ ブーツ screen calls. シャネル バッグ Everyone does. シャネル 財布 Sometimes you're シャネル 長財布 in the middle シャネル 靴 of something UGG and sometimes you UGG 新作 just don't feel アグ ブーツ like talking. UGG ブーツ But your phone UGG 通販 is still working ボッテガヴェネタ通販, and you see ボッテガヴェネタ靴新作 the missed call abercrombie uk and the voice message abercrombie uk online alert. So why abercrombie uk shop -- why?! -- do certain abercrombie people feel abercrombie men the need to abercrombie women send a text letting replica bags you know that they just left a message? Don't they realize that if someone is smart enough bag store online to read a text, they're also capable of understanding what the little bobble head with the sound waves coming out of him symbolizes? replica bags outlet Text back, "What's next, abercrombie and fitch uk a carrier pigeon?"You're ゼニアスポーツ靴新作 seeing a really ゼニアスポーツ通販 cute/smart/funny/cool new guy, ゼニアスポーツ激安 and your ゼニアスポーツ靴 heart skips a UGG 人気 tiny beat UGG 通販 every time UGG店舗 you get a UGG 通販 text from him. UGG激安 In the アグ middle of the week, UGG 人気 you get one asking what you're up UGG 新作 to this weekend UGG ブーツ.
UGG Tassel
UGG Tassel Sale
UGG Tassel
Tassel UGG Boots
In this modern and fashionable society, people are pursuing for thomas sabo cool, unique, stylish and innovative. Whether it is thomas sabo uk or fashion accessories all means a lot for modern society of today. Same is the case with trendy looking thomas sabo jewellery. When these are abercrombie, the excitement just gets doubled. Most chic looking abercrombie and fitch uk are in fashion now. These are one of the favorite fashion accessories for men and women long time ago. If you have not yet tried abercrombie uk, it's time to own one and feel the difference it can make to your personality. These are just brilliant and fabulous abercrombie & fitch sale. They are most iconic and can provide you with a new feeling and enhance confidence. The quality of burberry outlet is just superior to what you have dreamt of. Today owning a new and trendy looking burberry handbags are not only meant for the wealthy people. These are now made luxurious and affordable burberry outlet store to reach out to every budget and range. You can just enjoy them by ordering chloe bags online online where you get the complete satisfaction and genuine quality at best possible rates. The finish, quality and designs you get from chloe bags sale are really astonishing and you will love them all. Different styles and designs of chloe handbags sale are now available to make your wrist beautiful. You can choose from the wide variety of Cheap Chloe bags by comparing lots of perfect and stunning pieces.
So informative things are provided here,I really happy to read this post,I was just imagine about it and you provided me the correct information I really bookmark it,for further reading, So thanks for sharing the information. executive sales recruiters
<p>The Constitution charges timberland 6-inch premium boots with the task of taking care that the laws be faithfully executed, and yet the President has counseled his aides to commit perjury, willfully disregard the secrecy of grand jury proceedings, conceal surreptitious entry, timberland work shoes attempt to compromise a federal judge, while publicly displaying timberland mens boots with the processes of criminal justice. "a President is impeachable if he attempts to subvert the Constitution. "If the impeachment provision in the Constitution of timberland classic 3-eye handsewn will not reach the offenses charged here, then perhaps that 18th-century Constitution should be abandoned to a 20th-century paper shredder. Has the President committed offenses, timberland leisure shoes planned, and directed, and acquiesced in a course of conduct which the Constitution will not tolerate? That's the question. We know that. We know timberland roll top boots. We should now forthwith proceed to answer the question. It is reason, and not passion, which must guide our deliberations, guide our debate, and guide our decision. We have heard timberland on sale that the evidence reflects the payment to defendants money. The President had knowledge that roll top timberland were being paid and these were funds collected for the 1972 presidential campaign. We know that the President met with Mr. Henry Petersen 27 times to discuss timberland pro boots related to Watergate, and immediately thereafter met with the very persons who were implicated in the information Mr. Petersen was receiving. at this point, I would like to juxtapose a few of the impeachment timberland waterproof boots with some of the actions the President has engaged in. LJP</p>
<p align="center"></p>
<p>womens timberland boots</p>
<p>timberland boots uk</p>
<p>timberland classic boots</p>
Interesting article. Hoping that you will continue posting an article having a useful information. angry birds walk through
Thanks for your good website and for sharing your experiences.
Abercrombie
Abercrombie & Fitch
Abercrombie and Fitch
Abercrombie Milano
Abercrombie Fitch Milano
Abercrombie & Fitch Milano
Abercrombie and Fitch Milano
Abercrombie Italia
Abercrombie Fitch Italia
Abercrombie and Fitch Italia
Abercrombie
Abercrombie & Fitch
Abercrombie and Fitch
Abercrombie Milano
Abercrombie Fitch Milano
Abercrombie & Fitch Milano
Abercrombie and Fitch Milano
Abercrombie Italia
Abercrombie Fitch Italia
Abercrombie and Fitch Italia
Abercrombie
Abercrombie & Fitch
Abercrombie and Fitch
Abercrombie Milano
Abercrombie Fitch Milano
Abercrombie & Fitch Milano
Abercrombie and Fitch Milano
Abercrombie Italia
Abercrombie Fitch Italia
Abercrombie and Fitch Italia
Abercrombie
Abercrombie & Fitch
Abercrombie and Fitch
Abercrombie Milano
Abercrombie Fitch Milano
Abercrombie & Fitch Milano
Abercrombie and Fitch Milano
Abercrombie Italia
Abercrombie Fitch Italia
Abercrombie and Fitch Italia
The truth is, there is no better time than right now.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Abercrombie
Abercrombie & Fitch
Abercrombie and Fitch
Abercrombie Paris
Abercrombie Fitch Paris
Abercrombie & Fitch Paris
Abercrombie and Fitch Paris
Abercrombie France
Abercrombie Fitch France
Abercrombie and Fitch France
Abercrombie
Abercrombie & Fitch
Abercrombie and Fitch
Abercrombie Paris
Abercrombie Fitch Paris
Abercrombie & Fitch Paris
Abercrombie and Fitch Paris
Abercrombie France
Abercrombie Fitch France
Abercrombie and Fitch France
We have every right to dream heroic Karen Milen Sale dreams. Those who say that we’re in a time when there are no heroes -- timberland classic boot just don’t know where to look. You can see heroes every day going in and out of factory gates. Others, a handful in number, produce enough food to feed all of us and then Karen Millen Multicolor beyond. You meet heroes across a counter -- and they’re on both sides of that counter. Karen Millen Shop for women are entrepreneurs with faith in themselves and faith in an idea who create new jobs, new wealth and opportunity.