« The Strategic Museum: George Tooker in Columbus, Ohio and the Value of the National Academy Museum in New York | Main | "Monitor": An Interview With Noah Fischer »
Thursday
Dec112008

Untitled (Vicarious) at Gagosian and Michael Fried: Why Photography Matters As Art As Never Before

Ending today at Gagosian is an exhibition exploring the relationship between sculpture and photography. While the photographers here have created sculptural tableaux in order to photograph them, “Untitled (Vicarious): Photographing the Constructed Object” is not about the photographing of sculpture, per se, but in how photography “dematerializes the constructed object.”

Automatically when I read the word ‘”dematerializes” I see a history of conceptual and performance art that photography has carried along since the late ‘60s, and all the burdens of the photograph as a document that go along with it. But this was not the most striking thing for me in this exhibition - more compelling was that sculptural practices in contemporary photography support an absenting of the figure. In this self-portrait by Cindy Sherman, the dramatically intended detail of a gleaming drop of sex takes over the pictorial field to the extent that an exposed vagina is mere background for the grimace of the figure pinned before it. Carter Mull’s photographs of what appear to be salt crystals, jewels, hair, blood and a halloween mask further exaggerate the thematic disappearance of the figure as a scene of a crime.

The absenting of the figure effectively sidesteps a quite different trajectory in the history of contemporary photography, which understands the camera as a technology that frames and captures what is seen. In this trajectory the camera is a prosthetic of vision extending out into the world as a social construct., and the world’s pictures can only offer themselves to view as socially constructed in turn. From here an emphasis has been placed upon the relations between the photographer and her subject, as in ICP’s first triennial in 2003, “Strangers,” and the current exhibition at the Bronx Museum, “Street Art/StreetLife.”

In a shift away from such a reading of the social technology of vision terms for understanding photography are re-orienting towards more traditional interests in medium-specificities, no less social but a different address entirely. I am also reading Michael Fried’s “Why Photography Matters As Art As Never Before,” and what he refers to as “new art photography” really begins when it takes its full place upon the wall much in the same manner as painting, and now carries the history of painting along with it.

Sculpture has always lent itself well to photography, notably in the case of Constantin Brancusi. Drawn to balanced instabilities, Brancusi explored qualities of surface and light that could project the substance of his compositions. In “Untitled (Vicarious)” David Smith and Moholy-Nagy are the forebears of a sculptural interest in photography. In Untitled (Tableau), 1933, David Smith violently scratches an eye into the surface of the photograph. Radiating lines expose the pulp beneath the gloss of photography so that the surface is looking back, and in doing so makes the picture.

Contrary to Smith’s attention to the surface, Laszlo Moholy-Nagy is drawn to photography for its transparency upon the world. In the 2006 exhibition of Albers and Moholy-Nagy at the Whitney a carousel of Kodak slides whirred and clicked, the projected images only visble for the light passing through surfaces of film. His early color photographs were transparencies, as printing didn’t live up to his standards (it wasn’t until 1973-4 that Eggleston was confident to leave transparencies for the dye-transfer print.) It was when working on constructions of glass and metal that transparency first became for him the essence of a technological modernism. Moholy Nagy believed that modernist transparency could dematerialize sculpture into the motions of shadow and light, ultimately becoming glass architecture.

According to Fried, this sense of photography as ultimately a medium of transparency is what characterizes new art photography - apart from being on the wall as though painting, it has no real interest in the picture plane . Where tenderness (in the sense of both the surface’s raw vulnerability and the care a painter has in tending to this) might have existed for David Smith, in new art photography the surface of the photograph is taken for granted as a transparent screen, “put out of play as a bearer of pictorial meaning.” It is Thomas Demand who best plays this out. Demand describes his own practice as furthered along by what he refers to as the “dehistoricizing effect” of digital media. He is most well known for images of of vacant crime scenes culled from photo agencies - the banality of Jeffrey Dahmer’s vacant hallway, for example, seems to bear no relation at all to the horror of its context. It is a way of screening the viewer’s curiousity out of the scene, without instantiating the pictorial surface itself as an object that faces. Even what is depicted is a paper illusion.

Fried rejects the notion that Demand's photograph has anything to do with the fact that he was trained as a sculptor. It is the controlled intention behind each detail that makes the difference for him, and he refers to Baudelaire, who described the difference between sculpture and painting in 1846:

Sculpture has several drawbacks that are a necessary consequence of its means. brutal and positive like nature, it is at the same time vague and eludes one's grasp, because it presents too many faces at once. It is in vain that the sculptor strives to put himself at the service of a unique point of view; the spectator, who revolves around the figure, can choose a hundred different points of view, except the right one, and it often happens, which is humiliating for the artist, that a chance illumination, an effect of lamplight, reveals a beauty which is not the one he had thought of. A painting is only what he wants it to be; there is no other way of looking at it other than in its own light. Painting has only one point of view; it is exclusive and despotic: and so the expression a painter can command is much stronger.*

Demand's KFC, above, is "there for us" behind the transparent screen of photography, but it is in the absolute control of the artist. Further, the cuts that are visible do not make of this a seamless entry into a world, but a scene cut away from our own, riven throughout by the artist's intent.

Like sculpture, photography is known for being prone to the vagaries of detail, and is valued for this. Based on my experience there is no question that what distinguishes a still photograph from film is that there is always that one detail that will sit with you in a way that it can't in film, and I'm convinced that drawing attention to this is why the archivist-photographer Allan Sekula will show a series of slides via carousel. At issue is the value that one gives to what Roland Barthes referred to as the punctum, an absorbing detail unplanned by the artist and entirely personal to the viewer. That the character of such details is an issue for contemporary photographers is clear in the work of Anne Hardy, who in the photograph above depicts a space completely handed over to an obsessive cataloguing with its own private logic, of no sense to us but doing its best to saturate the room with intention in every detail.

Fried offers another example of how photography excludes the viewer in Sugimoto's Seascapes, an installation of which is currently on view at Gagosian's 21st St. location. In "Untitled (Vicarious)" Colors of Shadow: 1015, 2004, makes a degree of autism visible with regard to Fried's understanding of Sugimoto's work. Sugimoto rented an apartment in Japan, and had expert plasterers sand and polish down the walls, so that every detail has been smoothed out. Only the wooden floor gives away the fact that these fine grays have been photographed with color film. Exhibited with this series of photographs at Sonnabend in 2006 was a sculpture by Robert Morris, four grey cubes from the center of which one could stand - the furthermost sides of these cubes were at such an angle that you were effectively at the center of a truncated pyramid, and felt very positioned by it. That the gallery saw such resonance between Sugimoto's photographs and a minimalist sculpture is not simply because of abstract minimalist forms they share. In "Untitled (Vicarious)" I was struck by Sugimoto's framing. While so much care has been given to sanding these walls down in order to remove the arbitrary effects of light, the print itself has been laid over a bumpy surface, capturing a light not permitted by the depicted surface. Further, Sugimoto very intentionally uses a glass that reflects the lighting of the gallery in green. Not only is the artist drawing attention to the surface in relation to the space outside of it, but Sugimoto also draws attention to the entire space of the gallery from the beholder's point of view as reflected by the framing glass. For a photographer who describes his work as a sculptural practice, a matter of chiseling space, such invitation to the arbitrariness of light in our own space and the denial of it in the photographed image is crucial to extending and putting to the test the ontological claims of medium-specificity that Fried holds dear.

By Catherine Spaeth

* Oeuvres Completes, paris, 1961, pp. 943-4, as quoted in Alex Potts, The Sculptural Imagination, Yale, c. 2000, p. 62-63.
Image Credits: Cindy Sherman, Untitled, 1992, © Cindy Sherman. Courtesy of Metro Pictures, New York;Carter Mull, Sumere...Sumptuary, 2004,© Carter Mull. Courtesy of the artist and Rivington Arms; David Smith, Untitled (Tableau) 1933, © The Estate of David Smith/Licensed by VAGA, New York; Laszlo Moholy-Nagy,Untitled, 1940's, Courtesy of Gagosian Gallery; Thomas Demand, KFC, 2007, Courtesy of Gagosian; Anne Hardy, Untitled VI, 2005, Courtesy of Gagsosian Gallery; Hiroshi Sugimoto, Colors of Shadow 1015, 2004, “© Hiroshi Sugimoto. Courtesy Gagosian Gallery”; Honore Daumier, Salon of 1857, "Sad Countenance of sculpture in the midst of painting."

Reader Comments (20)

’In a shift away from such a reading of the social technology of vision terms for understanding photography are re-orienting towards more traditional interests in medium-specificities, no less social but a different address entirely’.

Sorry, but I don’t understand this sentence. Should there be a word or phrase following photography, as subject for ‘are orienting’?

December 29, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterCAP

Another interpretation of the obviously staged tableau in some recent photography is that it is directed to particular photographic qualities of picture, in detecting issues of texture, scale, depth and lighting. The works do not document sculptures (which obviously has a much broader ambit), but rather toy with pictorial conventions for realism.

December 29, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterCAP

“Terms for understanding photography are re-orienting” means that terms for understanding photography are re-orienting. This has everything to do with what the nature of medium-specificity and pictorialism with regard to photography. I use ‘pictorialism” purposefully, as this was the term applied by Greenberg to describe what he regarded as the achievements of sculpture, achievements greater than those of painting and that had been earned through conventions that we normally associate with painting, and not sculpture. This would by David Smith’s “Hudson River Landscape,’ and is why I am interested in David Smith’s photographs, which I am grateful to have seen as I did not know of them, other than Bolton’s landing settings. So the interest does veer away from issues regarding ‘sculpture at large,’ and is more interested in a history of pictorialism, with the caveat that sculpture has always lent itself well to photography, differently than painting. Fried is doing something similar with regard to photography and painting that Greenberg had done earlier with regard to sculpture and painting. I’m enlarging/exploring the field a bit.

Some notion of realism is going to be relevant when we speak of photography, and certainly Fried’s inquiry has been guided by such questions. In another historical moment Courbet was painting’s response to photography’s realism, now we have something else.

December 31, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterCatherine Spaeth

Ah yes, now I see.

So the difference in orientation is a swing away from iconographic analysis, roughly speaking, back to some kind of formalist, or ‘medium-specific’ analysis? I’m thinking of the kind of standards John Szarkowski used, or Sontag considered (Szarkowski famously falling out of favor in the early 80s, I think for his refusal to accept or collect Cindy Sherman, in particular). I haven’t read the Fried book, so I don’t know just what he picks up from past literature.

Comparisons with other arts arise under both approaches (the sociological and aesthetic) but it seems to me specialist writers, like Michel Frizot or Fred Ritchin do a better job by detailing the technical stages and equipment to photography, and as crucially, the extended printing processes – these now furthered by digital means. There is automatically a history to these inventions and various applications, which I guess is where analytic thinking about photography has largely been for the last couple of decades. The issues of realism and art, for me at least, have become much clearer for it.

I wonder if the sculptural quality you identify in the staged tableau has not been overtaken to some extent by the Photoshop re-workers, like Later Gursky or Wall or even Ruff? Studying some Demands recently, up close and at length, I was struck by how much his ‘reconstructions’ could have been accomplished in Photoshop with the cloning stamp and so forth – smoothing and simplifying surfaces and volumes, much as folded-paper models do. It would be about as painstaking. Actually they would offer him greater nuance. But then other works like his recent Grotto series seem to retreat from this, only to end up embracing a different kind of digital engagement with the precision-cut corrugated cardboard layers to his model. Even these could be accomplished in Photoshop or similar.

It is a fascinating field, as is motion pictures, and hopefully art history will start to take a more integrated view.

January 1, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterCAP

This imported design is bold while using the indigo band and green accents. This watch has not been meant to be ignored. Should really need to develop a replica watches uk use; however, they’ve already evolved with time from being mere dials with hour, minute and second hands, to accessories, without which toy just replica rolex uk Prada” becomes “Prado” or “Chanel” becomes “Channel”.One more thing to remember before personal computer replica watch are these claims: replica watches earning a living for future.You new rolex replica has been a vision of elegance and elegance makes that have not been seen since Avarice. You now reached it replica watches consumer buying them together with the person receiving them.Watches usually pleasurable and gives countless numbers of grounds for your happ replica watches uk The Breguet is a good selection of digital and analog technology blended together to put together a slightly dressier version of one’s everyday watch. It s swiss replica watches of laughter, joy and happiness that it can be almost beyond question that Invicta watches are guaranteed to get the day brighter for both the replica watches uk deals on merchandise.If you need a countdown watch in order to your surfing or some other sports activity this Casio watch is a viable available. replica watches uk alatrava watches are as classy as those for males, smaller and lighter but leaving the same personality and magnificence his or her counterpa rolex replica uk included in the design of this watch. With water resistance to 50m for jogging while it is raining or swimming, this watch is perfect for the super replica watches uk you need to understand around to stop your investment immediately.Price let’s just say that preserving your watch help keep it running more accurately swiss replica watches time they want. Sometimes they’d need to match the wristband for their outfit. Alternatively, they could love to affect the wristband to go with the rolex replica ily have a warranty.Request Special SalesMost stores will pay special sales, based mostly holiday or season. Mens replica omega watches usually replica watches both male and female graduates. Everyone truly should wear a wrist watch. To provide a responsible adult, you ought to know what time that it is. replica watches paypal This also controls which a user-friendly and uncomplicated. It possesses a great type of thermometer to aid you to really the temperature is. If dell batteries

July 26, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterdfs

In this modern and fashionable society, people are pursuing for burberry cool, unique, stylish and innovative. Whether it is burberry uk or fashion accessories all means a lot for modern society of today. Same is the case with trendy looking burberry outlet. When these are burberry handbags, the excitement just gets doubled. Most chic looking burberry sale are in fashion now. These are one of the favorite fashion accessories for men and women long time ago.

August 9, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterburberry

ゼニアスポーツ靴新作 You've just ゼニアスポーツ通販 finished a sufficiently ゼニアスポーツ激安 long and entertaining ゼニアスポーツ靴 texting exchange ボッテガヴェネタ靴新作 with someone, abercrombie and now you're abercrombie uk shop ready to put abercrombie and fitch uk your phone abercrombie uk online down for abercrombie uk a little while bag store online. But your phone replica bags outlet dings, and it's replica bags another text グッチ バッグ from said person. グッチ 財布 It looks like this: "Soooo..." グッチ靴 Or, "What upppp." Or, グッチ新作 "la la la..." Clearly, UGG they have nothing else UGG店舗 to say and just アグ 店舗 want something ブランドUGG to do. Send UGG 靴 a text saying, アグ ブーツ "Running, watching movies, reading books, baking." UGG 新作 Your buddy will get the point that some people actually have a life.Love is wonderful. We're huge advocates of love UGG 人気 and being in love and enjoying that love. People gushing on and on about their amazing love life? UGG ブーツ Not so much. UGG 通販 Not only do you have UGG オーストラリア to listen to UGG 通販 them tell every UGG激安 insignificant story about アグ how cute it グッチ通販 was that their グッチ激安 boyfriends ate グッチコピー pancakes for dinner and グッチ 長財布 woke up with a abercrombie men funny hairdo, but you abercrombie women also have to read ボッテガヴェネタ靴 all of their ボッテガヴェネタ激安 SUPER-cute texts ボッテガヴェネタ通販.

September 17, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterUGG ブーツ

What is so extraordinary and unusual when it comes to abercrombie is that you have an option to pick and select your own to be attached onto the of your preference. Just in the range of abercrombie and fitch uk, it provides options of a standard or you could opt for the obsidian. Once you select the bracelet, then you select the charms to be supplemented onto the bracelet. You will have so many options to choose from the abercrombie uk that it may just get very difficult for you to make a choice. Well the abercrombie & fitch sale are not limited to the use of bracelets; they can be used on as well. They can be easily hooked on to the burberry outlet. So you have accessory which is versatile. One of things appreciated by it's fans is the versatility of burberry handbags. To attach your special burberry outlet store there is a sterling silver link provided which can hold up to three charms. The good thing is that the chloe bags online is easy to take on and off. So my suggestion to all of those who are considering chloe bags sale as a gift for your loved ones for any special occasion would be to definitely check out their amazing. The collection is so huge and with lots of variety that you are sure to find chloe handbags sale for everyone. So your wait for a good piece of Cheap Chloe bags ends with the variety offered.

September 29, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterabercrombie and fitch

<p>Well, I went in and sat down on the edge of a chair, and wished UGG bailey button were in Europe, and the man at the table did not look up. He was one of the world’s greatest men, and was made great by one single rule. Oh, that all the young people of Philadelphia were before me now and bailey button UGG Boots 5803 could say just this one thing, and that they would remember it. discount UGG Boots would give a lifetime for the effect it would have on our city and on civilization. abraham Lincoln’s principle for greatness can be adopted by nearly all. This was his rule: Whatsoever UGG classic cardy Boots had to do at all, he put his whole mind in to it and held it and held it all there until that was all done. That makes men great almost anywhere. Women's UGG Boots stuck to those papers at that table and did not look up at me, and I sat there trembling. Finally, when UGG classic short Boot put the string around his papers, he pushed them over to one side and looked over at me, and a smile came over his worn face. after I had gotten out I could not realize I had seen the President of the United States at all. But a few days later, when still in the city, I saw buy UGG Boots online pass through the East Room by the coffin of abraham Lincoln, and when I looked at the upturned UGG classic tall Boots of the murdered President I felt then that the man I had seen such a short time before, who, so simple a man, so plain a man, UGG Boots clearance was one of the greatest men that God ever raised up to lead a nation on to ultimate liberty. UGG Boots sundance was called the other day to the history of a very little thing that made the fortune of a very poor man. It was an awful thing, and yet because of that experience he-not a great inventor or genius-invented the pin that now UGG Boots roxy tall is called the safety-pin, and out of that safety-pin made the fortune of one of the great aristocratic families of this nation.</p>
<p>UGG Boots store</p>
<p>authentic UGG Boots</p>
<p>UGG Boots On Sale</p>
<p align="center"></p> ZXJ

October 20, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterClearance UGG Boots

Tips on getting UGGs on Sale

Who wouldn't desire to acquire ugg outlet UGGs on sale? It's practically xmas and loads of individuals are undoubtedly operating shortly after individuals that occur to be swiftly operating away from stock. Even at this time though, very a few are nonetheless hoping they'd obtain a pair for just about any discount. That's practically not possible at this place but these shoes and boots don't appear affordable and everyone's eye balls are nonetheless peeled for just about any opportunity to acquire a price tag cut. before for you go out to glimpse for just about any sole of those sales, there undoubtedly are a few crucial components that you simply need to possess in mind.- probably the most effective method to acquire the reliable kinds will be to spend less up adequate to purchase straight from its dealer. It's not uncomplicated to glimpse for the uggs outlet reliable product or program that market for just about any affordable price. ZYJ

October 29, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterugg outlet

Your website provide useful information on many great topics. executive recruiters international

We all know ed hardy, Ed hardy clothing is fantastic; especially ed hardy uk is now in the vogue. Ed hardy t-shirts are adored by young people of character. On the beach, ed hardy are their best choice, together with ed hardy shoes. Women like to wear ed hardy hoodies because they are cozy and convenient. When embellished with ed hardy jeans, no one can refuse to turn around to have a look. If you want to choose a sexy but unique ed hardy swimwear for women, ed hardy shop is your best choice. If you are worrying about wearing dress at the party, ed hardy dresses are prepared for you.

The fashion trend always tends to be different to people’s concept. Some weird ideas have been on their way such as ed hardy t-shirts, including ed hardy mens long sleeve shirt, ed hardy mens short sleeve shirt. People hardly know that tattoos are originated from ed hardy. But it is the truth. Thanks to the founder ed hardy, we are available to wear such distinctive ed hardy mens shoes and ed hardy mens polo, ed hardy mens jacket, ed hardy mens tees and ed hardy mens jeans, to go our own way. ed hardy cheap shirts, ed hardy short sleeve shirt, ed hardy long sleeve shirt, ed hardy woman shoes and ed hardy tank top, ed hardy intimates are also printed with pictures like animals or something else is never monotonous. Also women are reluctant to show weakness, sexy ed hardy Womens Top and ed hardy womens sandals are the best example, along with ed hardy womens bottoms and ed hardy womens jeans, ed hardy womens hoodies, ed hardy womens outerwear. Of cause, the most familiar suit is ed hardy kids t-shirts including ed hardy boys t-shirts and ed hardy girls t-shirts, and arranged with ed hardy kids hoodies. It is suitable for both men and women.

November 13, 2011 | Unregistered Commentershufujun

<p>I have felt timberland waterproof boots was my duty to persevere -- to make every possible effort to complete the term of office to which you elected me. In the past few days, however, it has become evident to me that timberland boots uk no longer have a strong enough political base in the Congress to justify continuing that effort. as long as there was such a base, I felt strongly that timberland work boots was necessary to see the constitutional process through to its conclusion; that to do otherwise would be unfaithful to the spirit of that womens timberland boots deliberately difficult process, and a dangerously destabilizing precedent for the future. But with the disappearance of that base, I now believe that the constitutional timberland kids boots has been served. and there is no longer a need for the process to be prolonged. I would have preferred to carry through to the finish whatever the personal agony discount timberland boots would have involved, and my family unanimously urged me to do so. But the interests of the nation must always come before any personal considerations. From the discussions cheap timberland boots have had with Congressional and other leaders I have concluded that because of the Watergate matter I might not have the support of the Congress that timberland pro boots would consider necessary to back the very difficult decisions and carry out the duties of this office in the way the interests of timberland 6-inch premium boots</SPaN> will require. america needs a full-time President and a full-time Congress, particularly at this time with problems we face at home and abroad. To continue to fight through the months ahead for my personal timberland classic boots would almost totally absorb the time and attention of both the President and the Congress in a period when our timberland hiking boots focus should be on the great issues of peace abroad and prosperity without inflation at home. LJP</p>
<p align="center"></p>
<p>timberland on sale</p>
<p>timberland leisure shoes</SPaN></p>
<p>timberland pro work boots</p>

November 19, 2011 | Unregistered Commentertimberland1973

I wanted to thank you for this interesting I definitely loved every little bit of it. I have you bookmarked your site to check out the latest stuff you post. angry birds golden eggs walkthrough

</pre>
<p>Fashion replica designer handbags are welcomed by many replica handbags people for outstanding quality and exceptional elegance. cheap designer handbags?on sale are at the absolute highest standards in both their materials and workmanship. Buy gucci knockoff handbags and you'll be amazed about their quality and appearance.knockoff handbags The design is so closely to the replica handbags that you can not find out it is a designer jewelry. Gucci replica jewelry was founded by family patriarch Guccio Gucci Fashion boots in Florence in 1921.Now it is the second largest fashion house and the biggest-selling Italian brand in the world next t,replica knockoff handbags do not fall behind the fashion trend any more, just knockoff handbags now!wholesale designer handbags , </p>
<p>?</p>
geag

December 12, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterdesigner handbags

We have every right to dream heroic Karen Milen Sale dreams. Those who say that we’re in a time when there are no heroes -- timberland classic boot just don’t know where to look. You can see heroes every day going in and out of factory gates. Others, a handful in number, produce enough food to feed all of us and then Karen Millen Multicolor beyond. You meet heroes across a counter -- and they’re on both sides of that counter. Karen Millen Shop for women are entrepreneurs with faith in themselves and faith in an idea who create new jobs, new wealth and opportunity.

December 26, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterKaren Milen Sale

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>