« Flags of Revolt and Defiance: Polly Apfelbaum | Main | David Diao: A Picaresque Tale of Ruins »
Monday
May122008

After May: Paula Cooper's Inaugural Show, 1968

DateMonday, May 12, 2008 at 02:58PM


During the auction house bidding already begun over at Artworld Salon, we have to fess up to an artworld driven as much by history and the engaged dialogue of criticism as by the numbers game. That this awareness hits us in May 2008, the 40th year anniversary of May 1968, is the sad fact of our war and disaster-ridden time. Reading Arthur Danto’s take on the student take-over of Columbia doesn’t assuage the mood. He writes, “I have a kind of theory that when great social changes are about to take place, something happens in the arts first - think of Romanticism and the French Revolution...” and that “Columbia students back then had little interest in advanced art as such.”*

In France they already thought they knew this about America. The 1966 student manifesto “On the Poverty of Student Life” explains that Americans did not have a theory and as a result their actions ‘were spontaneous mass movements which collapsed because they proved incapable of grasping more than the incidental aspects of alienation,”and that American students would never come to understand that everyday life is controlled by the “psycho-humanist police force.”** Because the events of May were so huge in Paris, and artists so involved, artists there were faced with how to continue to practice on the heels of May - one example is that the Comite du Salon de la Jeune Peinture committed itself to the Communist Party, desiring to continue the project of the Atelier Populiare to change the structure of the artist’s relation to capital.

In the New York October of 1968, Paula Cooper’s inaugural gallery show was the “Exhibition to Benefit the Student Mobilization Committee to End the War in Vietnam.” Along with Lucy Lippard and Ron Wolin the exhibition was primarily curated by Robert Huot, whose work was at that time traveling in “The Art of the Real,” MoMA’s USIA-funded show, just closed in September and about to open in Paris. Lucy Lippard described the Paula Cooper show as “a kind of protest show against the potpourri peace shows with all those burned doll’s heads,” and the first benefit exhibition of non-objective art.*** The statement of the exhibition was that:

“These fourteen non-objective artists are against the war in Vietnam. They are supporting this commitment by contributing major examples of their current work. The artists and the particular pieces were selected to represent a particular aesthetic attitude in the conviction that a cohesive group of important works makes the most forceful statement for peace.”

In appealing to an aesthetic attitude the artists were likely thinking of the recent exhibition curated by Barbara Rose, “Towards a New Aesthetic”, held at the Washington Gallery of Modern Art in 1967. Arguing that there is nothing to constitute a style or a school in the history of American art, Rose believed that the literalism Michael Fried condemned in “Art and Objecthood” was in fact a powerful moment in contemporary art and the measure of its success. E.C. Goossen’s “The Art of the Real,” soon followed, and there was overlap between artists in each, artists who were quite willing to adopt the rhetoric of “the real” as an expression of a specifically American “aesthetic attitude.”

However, the exhibition statement prompted critic Gregory Battcock to write that while he very much liked the exhibition, in these terms it might as well be a wine tasting or a fashion show, and that “We are, as usual, being sold a package. The Modern philosophy of Madison Avenue and the packaging technologist has become everyday fact.”****And Leo Steinberg was critical of the rhetoric of the real as well, in his lecture “Other Criteria,” read at MoMA only months before the opening of The Art of the Real, stating that contemporary art has become the technological research in which the art object ‘”is declared at last to be a real thing, possessed of more “reality” than mere art ever had.”*****

The language that surrounds this show - the curator’s desires to articulate what is art historically of note for their time, and the condemnation of these attempts as mere packaging for a growing market impressed by clean and technical professionalism, belong to it equally and are by now familiar. Responding in a quite physical way to the photo of Bill Bollinger’s floor-to-ceiling tension cable as sculpture, and to the art historical fact that it was in this show that Sol Lewitt made his very first wall drawings, I find this divide to be a curious moment in the history of American art, a moment in which to have an aesthetic attitude was at the same time to get real.

As a “cohesive group of important works,” standing together to fund student opposition to war, does such an attitude count for something more than what any of these works might bring in todays auctions?

The artists: Carl Andre, Jo Baer, Robert Barry, Bill Bollinger, Dan Flavin, Robert Huot, Will Insley, Donald Judd, Sol Lewitt, Robert Mangold, Doug Ohlson, Robert Ryman.

By Catherine Spaeth

*Arthur C. Danto, “Before the Revolution,” in Artforum, May 2008, p. 100.
**Members of the Situationist International and the Students of Strasbourg, “On the Poverty of Student Life Considered in it’s Economic, Political, Psychological, Sexual and Particularly Intellectual Aspects, and a Modest Proposal for its Remedy,” in Beneath the Paving Stones: Situationists and the Beach, May 1968, texts collected by Dark Star, London, :A/K Press, c. 2001, p. 26.
***As quoted by Grace Glueck, Artnotes, Sunday October 27th, 1968.
****Gregory Battcock, “Reviewing the Above Statement,” in New York Free Press Critique, 31, October 1968.
Leo Steinberg, “Other Criteria,” in Other criteria, NY: Oxford University press, c. 1972, p. 1963.

Image Credits: Installation views from "Exhibition to Benefit Student Mobilization Committee to End the War in Vietnam," October 1968. Installation 1, Will Insley, Jo Baer; Installation 2, Carl Andre, Doug Ohlson; Installation 3, Robert Huot, Dan Flavin; Installation 4, Robert Mangold, Bill Bollinger, and Donald Judd. All images courtesy of Paula Cooper Gallery.

Catherine Spaeth

AuthorCatherine Spaeth | Comment19 Comments |
tagged , , ,

Reader Comments (19)

Excellent Blog...glad I found a new source for checking out what's new and hot in the Arts...Thanks for writing good content!!!

June 12, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterManuel Pereira da Silva

Thanks, Manuel - I've been on blog hiatus but will be back in a few days...

June 13, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterCatherine Spaeth

glad to know art can be supporting anything, especially for education

June 16, 2008 | Unregistered Commentertorasham

This is a brilliant post that tied some things together for me. Thank you!

July 11, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterMichael

Michael, your blogs are excellent! Back atcha.

July 11, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterCatherine Spaeth

Thanks!

All the posts from my blogs (art, religion&technology, politics, bicycles, plants) are aggregated at

fieldgallery.org

July 11, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterMichael

We sac ed hardy highly recommend
sac fendi users remove

sac gucci pas cher all older versions
sac jimmy choosac of Java from

sac juicy your system.

July 4, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterdd

If you ever critically Christian Louboutin wish to come up with a desire Louboutin to the youngsters then, christian louboutin uk you'll find degree of more effective methods christian louboutin shoes to accomplish so louboutin shoes rather than provide christian louboutin sale outside hang on units to make sure that that they louboutin sale possess a playground of their individual garden.The christian louboutin shoes Christian Louboutin Boots is during actuality a swing that provides Jimmy Choo a exceptional destination.f you ever critically Christian Louboutin wish to come up with a desire Louboutin to the youngsters then, christian louboutin uk you'll find degree of more effective methods christian louboutin shoes to accomplish so louboutin shoes rather than provide christian louboutin sale outside hang on units to make sure that that they louboutin sale possess a playground of their individual garden.The christian louboutin shoes Christian Louboutin Boots is during actuality a swing that provides Jimmy Choo a exceptional destination.The nintendo ds lite card enables you to explore a complete extraordinary universe of games and apps on the nds lite And DSi Nintendo Cards what does an ndsl Card can help you play? Nintendo DS Lite Console grants you egereggre hundreds, Homebrew games have already been accessible for countless years even for the GBA and in truth arrivedonto their own when the NDS Lite cardswas released for your.Use many of the Nintendo DS Accessories are remakes of Nintendo DS Card we all believe and enjoy.

July 9, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterlouboutin

contented mind is the greatest blessing a man can enjoy in this world.-Richard Mille RM005 watches Swiss

July 22, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterRichard Mille RM005 watches Swiss

I really got into this article. I found it to be interesting and loaded with unique points of interest. I like to read material that makes me think. Thank you for writing this great content. Pandora UK Pandora UKPandora Jewellery Pandora JewelleryPandora Jewellery UK Pandora Jewellery UKpandora bracelets pandora braceletspandora charms pandora charmspandora beads pandora beadsTommy Hilfiger Tommy HilfigerTommy Hilfiger UK Tommy Hilfiger UKTommy Hilfiger Clothing Tommy Hilfiger ClothingTommy Mens Polos Tommy Mens PolosTommy Men's Shirts Tommy Men's ShirtsTommy Mens Shorts Tommy Mens ShortsTommy Mens T-Shirts Tommy Mens T-ShirtsTommy Mens Sweaters Tommy Mens Sweaterspandora necklaces pandora necklacespandora necklace pandora necklacepandora sale pandora salepandora beads pandora beadsFashion Jewellery Fashion JewelleryDiy Jewellery Diy JewelleryJewellery Blog Jewellery BlogPandora Jewellery Pandora JewelleryTommy Mens Shoes Tommy Mens ShoesTommy Womens Polos Tommy Womens PolosTommy Mens Shirts Tommy Mens Shirts

August 16, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterTommy Hilfiger UK

It seems like you do have a great knowledge about blog engine. Pretty much sure your post would be lot more help for the readers who need more info about blog engine

September 28, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterNorth Face Men’s Bionic Jackets

エルメス バッグ Love is not エルメス 財布 possessive. エルメス 長財布 As you like エルメス 激安 the moon but エルメス 通販 it's impossible to UGG bring the moon アグ down and UGG激安 keep it. But UGG 通販 the moonlight will UGG店舗 still shine into アグ 店舗 your room. ブランドUGG In thesame way, UGG 靴 you canposses UGG オーストラリア the person you love UGG 通販 in a different manner. UGG ブーツ Let the one you アグ ブーツ love remails in your UGG 新作 memory always. UGG 人気 You can't say why when ブランド 靴 you truly love someone. ブランド靴 新作 You oly know ブランド靴 激安 at any moment, ブランド靴 通販 in good mood or bad, ブランド靴 取扱店 you just want abercrombie uk this person by your abercrombie uk online side; True love abercrombie and fitch uk is when two people abercrombie uk shop are able towithstand abercrombie the worst times, abercrombie men yet not demanding abercrombie women anything from each other. replica bags After all, love requires one to give, replica bags outlet and not just receiving.If you really love someone, you need to love who he is--love his good, and his bad. Love his strengths and his weaknesses. bag store online Never wish that he'll change to become the person you want him to be because エルメス コピー you love him エルメス 新作.

October 11, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterUGG ブーツ

burberry is incredibly popular, and the collectable nature of these beautiful pieces of means that many people are searching for them online. As with any designer label, there will always be companies selling burberry handbags, however when you are buying online how can you be sure that what you are purchasing is the genuine . If you are buying directly from the official michael kors bags, then you are of course going to be getting the real deal. However there are many resellers, and smaller michael kors dresses stores which may have special offers or stock a particular item which you cannot find elsewhere. Thankfully, michael kors sandals are forward thinking, and give the stores which they supply to online a "Certified Online Retailer" badge which they can display on their websites. If you are still unsure about whether or not the site is genuine, you could always visit the genuine michael kors totes website and do a store search for the online retailer. If they appear in michael kors satchel listings then they are sure to be an authentic reseller. If you are looking to buy some more charms to add to your abercrombie, but are considering buying charms which are not official then there are a few things to consider. Firstly, the abercrombie and fitch uk may not fit well, either with hole being too small for the, or too big - so that the bead may move around more, causing more wear to the beads on either side. Also, are all made with silver or gold centres, which minimises the amount of wear on abercrombie uk worn side by side. Another make of may use harder, cheaper metals, which could scratch and damage genuine abercrombie uk Another make of may use harder, cheaper metals, which could scratch and damage genuine abercrombie & fitch sale

October 31, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterabercrombie and fitch

Wonderful.. I will bookmark your blog and take the feeds also...I am satisfied to find so much useful info here in the post. Thank you for sharing...Small Business Opportunities

November 12, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterSmall Business Opportunities

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>

Notify me of follow-up comments via email.